This week I finished two zines, both by the same pair of authors, Diana Smith and Pat Dunn. Overall, I would definitely seek out works by these two again - it's clear that they know their stuff and do good character work.
1. The French Songbird Affair
I bought this primarily because it is situated in the St. Crispin's Day Universe (
set right after Warriors), a place I always love to visit. In terms of the story, Napoleon and Illya are sent to protect the widow-in-all-but-law of a murdered UNCLE agent in the 1960s, a tale unfolds involving her espionage activities in occupied France in the '40s. If you are at all familiar with the way fiction works, you will not be surprised to learn that the flashback eventually becomes highly relevant to the series timeline A-plot.
I found the zine to be very well done. It's clearly extremely well researched. You spend a lot of time with original characters, especially in the flashback sequences, which are roughly 1/2 the text. The original characters are well drawn and I found their story to be engaging, but if you are someone who loses interest when the focus is not on our guys, this may not be the zine for you, despite its definite quality.
2. The String Theory Affair (The Man from Uncle/
Quantum Leap 1989 Crossover)
I saw that this won a FanQ, and I like both fandoms, so I figured I'd give it a shot.
This zine is split into two pretty distinct parts, although the two halves do come together at the end through a recurring antagonist (if you, like me, read this in conjunction with The French Songbird Affair, you may notice a bit of a structural pattern, but not a bad one, imo.) The first section, 'A Mole in the System,' I found highly enjoyable. Sam Beckett is a really fun outside POV character, because his is very much an outside perspective, but at the same time he is right in the action, and experiences everything that Illya or Napoleon would (he occupies both of their bodies at different points in the plot - if you don't know what Quantum Leap is, don't worry about it). I also thought there was a really nice balance between scenes set in the MFU universe and scenes set at the Quantum Leap base. I wasn't expecting to see much of the 90's characters at all, so that was a nice surprise and there are a few scenes with Illya and Ziggy that are really delightful.
This zine almost lost me in the second half though -- 'Part II: The Americanization of Illya,' in which Illya goes undercover in Elk Ridge, Indiana to look over a young Sam Beckett. This part didn't work for me for reasons that I expect have more to do with me than with it. As a queer Jew, the concept of 'Americanization,' and the plot of an outsider character acculturating to a normative Midwestern [read white, Protestant, straight] family made me a bit itchy, especially the scenes set at church. While there were some moments of cultural exchange, all the American characters seemed to get out of the experience was a stronger feeling of 'oh boy, we're sure glad we don't live in the USSR,' which is perhaps fair but felt somewhat incomplete, and I would have liked to see more depth into Illya's feelings about the way he presented himself and his background while undercover. The Becketts were somewhat aggressively wholesome in a way that, again, made me uncomfortable, but may not have the same effect on you.
The story picked up towards the end, when Napoleon arrived, and I did enjoy the conclusion. TLDR, it's a fun story, I liked 2/3 of it, and might have liked all of it if not for my own particular identity complex.